National Farmers Union Ontario wants to see the raw milk market regulated

This story, titled “Time to get raw milk out of the grey and black market” was sent to us by Pam Killeen. It’s from the National Farmers Union Ontario and is by Grant Robertson:

Farmer Michael Schmidt -- pictured here in his farm milkroom -- may have opened the door to new niche market possibilities for farmers. But the National Farmers Union feels regulation is needed.

It is time for a grown up discussion about raw milk.  For far too long the discussion has been centred on whether or not drinking raw milk will kill you, or whether it will cure everything under the sun.  The truth, like most things, is probably somewhere in the middle.  Let’s also be frank, there was good reason that government moved to require the pasteurization of milk and those moves undoubtedly saved countless lives over the intervening decades.

With the decision in a Newmarket court that ruled in favour of Durham, Ontario dairy farmer Michael Schmidt and his raw milk co-operative, the need to have that grown up discussion is more important than ever.  Schmidt was vindicated in the ruling which essentially amounted to a decision that those purchasing the shares in his dairy enterprise were aware of the risks raw milk could potentially contain and as aware consumers of the raw milk, had a right to drink it.   There was more to it of course, but that seems to be the essence of the ruling.  While the ruling was specifically about the Schmidt venture it has wider implications that can no longer be ignored.

Raw milk is sold in many jurisdictions around the world in tightly controlled food safety environments.  With modern food safety protocols those jurisdiction have come to the conclusion that raw milk can be sold safely to consumers.  In some ways Michael Schmidt’s success in the court room has almost been too successful.  Without a regulatory regime in place to protect potential drinkers of raw milk, Schmidt’s success has now potentially opened the door to others who may not be as fastidious as he in ensuring the safest possible product.  That potential was always there of course, but those looking at dollar signs rather than any other consideration may now feel they have an opportunity that was too risky to try before.

Pasteurization was brought in to protect the public.  Organizations like the Dairy Farmers of Canada and Ontario through the mechanism of supply management have worked very hard to create food safety protocols on the farm that address many of the underlying problems that led to the need for pasteurization in the first place.  Some of the supporters of raw milk want to treat the DFC and DFO as villains.  The truth is these organizations, while not perfect, are heroes in creating a system that works well for family farmers and protects the health and well-being of milk drinkers with a safe, nutritious product.

The ball is now firmly in their court and once again it will need to be these organizations who step up and develop, with consultation of course, the necessary food safety protocols that will protect consumers, and other dairy farmers from those who might try to cut corners and inadvertently endanger the milk consuming public.  But DFC and DFO will not be able to do this alone- government is going to have to stop its hands off approach, hoping that the courts would make a problem disappear and instead get actively involved and show some leadership.

It is evident there is a market for raw mile, both from other jurisdictions and from the success of the Schmidt enterprise.  It is far better to have this market served by a strict regulatory process from farm to glass than to have it exist in a black or grey market with little real oversight beyond the diligence of some of the people involved.  Rules are not created for those who would do the right thing no matter what.  It would only take one person to get sick from one source that was not as diligent as they should have been and all dairy farmers, of every sort, would be affected negatively.  We already have a system that works very well in the interests of farmers and drinkers.  It is time for raw milk to be regulated and overseen by those agencies that already have the most expertise and with a track record second to none, and a home found for raw milk producers within the supply managed systems.

Grant Robertson is the senior elected official with the National Farmers Union-Ontario.  As Ontario Coordinator Robertson is also a National Board Member of the NFU. Grant and his family farm near Paisley, Ontario.  The author can be contacted at

If you have been forwarded this commentary and would like to be added to the distribution list please send an email to with “subscribe” in the subject line.


Filed under News

5 responses to “National Farmers Union Ontario wants to see the raw milk market regulated

  1. what absolute crap. This crybaby damage control tempts me to use one of the most lewd, vulgar expressions in the English language ( but I won’t)

    as my old man used to say = “there’s nothing so useless it can’t at least be used as a bad example” this bleat to the NFU articulates the studied ignorance of the selfish monopolists who prevented two generations of Canadians from getting the nutrition we needed.

    thanks for the comic relief for the day, Mister Grant Roberson … your assertion that your pals in these agencies are the ones ‘with the best track record for regulating raw milk’ is laughable. They may be good little aparatchiks in Karl Marx’s system of industrialized agriculture, but they proved nothing better than that they’re idiots when it comes to understanding what consumers want
    As you enjoyed your Stalinist quota system, time and circumstance passed you by. The Berlin wall crumbled overnight l the milk marketing system – which did to Canada what communism does to every nation it touches … blighted the place – is a slow motion train wreck. But your pals and the politicians refuse to admit it. The proponents of par-boiled milk were so vehement to outlaw producers of REAL MILK = because the small holder providing for his community in a genuinely free market, exposes the dairy cartel for the red fascist racket it is.

  2. Bernie Bailey

    As the owner of the last small pasteurizing dairy in western Ontario who was forced out of business when the dairy farmers simply quit shipping milk to my plant as instructed by Bill Moore of the Ontario Farm Products Marketing Commission over an unwritten policy that I did not obey I have watched this unfold with great interest. I have one question that I would like anyone to answer –why dose our government and the bureaucrats think small companies and FARMERS are to stupid to sell their own products

  3. pete

    The persecution of raw milk producers is because those same producers are avoiding the system this article advocates. This isn’t about safety, its about slavery.

  4. thebovine

    Owen Sound Sun Times picks up this story Feb 21, 2010:

  5. aed939

    Translation of this article: the milk processors don’t like the fact that farmers may decide to sell raw milk directly to consumers, which puts a check on how low they can depress the wholesale price of raw milk. So they want the government to impose additional costs on raw milk sales to price it out of the market and increase the price differential between raw milk and processed milk.

    I would more than welcome regulated farm-to-consumer retail sales of milk (supply chain length=1) as long as the unregulated share ownership private club (Schmidt model, supply chain length=0) is still an option. If the government’s regulations get excessive due to milk processing lobbyists trying to price raw milk out of the market (more than necessary to assure a reasonable level of safety), farmers could revert to the Schmidt model.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s