A Tale of Two Calves –The Taste Test

You may remember a few posts back, that the CAVA restaurant in Toronto was planning to host a taste test of Michael Schmidt’s “two calves”. Well, here’s a report of the results of that Taste Test, excerpted from the Food Network.ca blog, along with photos, some from that blog, and others courtesy of CAVA:

Notice the colour difference between liver from calf A (left) and liver from calf B (right) -- Can you guess which calf was raised on raw milk vs. pasteurized milk? Photo via Food Network.ca

“Truth be told, I get invited my share of dinners although not as many as you may think. At the beginning I would say yes to pretty much any event that would have me. But after learning the hard way (hello, fat pants), I’m a bit more discerning now about the events I attend. Plus, I have a little one at home, so the event has to pretty darn special to get me out of my fat pants AND away from my son. That’s a looooong winded way of saying I wouldn’t have missed A Tale of Two Calves dinner at Cava Restaurant Tuesday night for anything.

Dairy farmer and activist Michael Schmidt – he of the raw milk controversy – provided Chef Chris McDonald, owner/executive chef of Cava Restaurant, with two 5-month-old calves, born on the same day, but one was fed raw milk while the other was fed commercial pasteurized milk.

Chef Chris McDonald and Farmer and raw milk activist Michael Schmidt - the two have been friends for over 15 years. Photo via Food Network.ca

Would there be a taste difference? That’s exactly what the 70 or so people packed inside Cava Restaurant, including Sean Heather (AKA Mayor of Gastown, who flew in from Vancouver for the event), were there to find out. Michael didn’t even tell Chef Chris which was which. The two calves were handed to him simply labelled A and B.

Chef Chris decided to start with the organs since he figured the differences would be most noticeable. He immediately noticed during his prep of the first dish – calf livers “anticuchos” – that calf B’s liver was redder, bigger and firmer than calf A’s. As you can see in the picture above, A is definitely grayer in colour; there was also a huge taste difference. I found A more subtle in taste whereas B was more intense in flavour and firmer in texture. While I preferred the taste of B, I was pretty convinced that A was the calf raised on raw milk since the taste was more subtle.

Calf Comparison: Eye of Round and Tete De Veau Terrines - calf A on top and to the right of the plate. Photo via Food Network.ca

Then it was on to the next course – Calf Comparison: Eye of Round with Line Caught Albacore Sauce and Tete De Veau Terrines. Here things got a bit confusing. Both Elana and I preferred the terrine of A – more flavourful but liked the eye of round of Calf B better. It was less mealy and had a better flavour. I did notice calf A was a bit greyer in colour overall.  At this point I felt less confident about A being the raw-milk raised calf….”

Read the whole thing here on the Food Network.ca blog.

"How many of you?" -- Raw milk farmer Michael Schmidt addresses the diners at CAVA.

Fine dining at the CAVA taste test.

Elise and Michael

Wine was also a part of the evening's festivities.

A glimpse of the menu.

Chef Chris McDonald with farmer Michael Schmidt at CAVA taste test event.

If you haven’t read it already, check out part 1 of our Tale of Two Calves report, showing photos of the calves and of their internal organs.


Filed under News

4 responses to “A Tale of Two Calves –The Taste Test

  1. Pingback: Food writer Kelly Jones shares her unique perspective on the Tale of Two Calves culinary experience at Cava « The Bovine

  2. Pingback: What Did We Learn from Michael Schmidt’s “Tale of Two Calves” Experiment? « Food In America

  3. Pingback: Canadian Chefs Attend Slow Food Raw Milk Cheese Workshop | Slow Food Canada

  4. Was reading this and followed the link to Foodnetwork. They have now taken down the results of the taste test. Maybe you could repost this one here. As I have just now found this.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s