Wikileaks show how U.S. bullied Europe to permit use of Monsanto’s GMO seeds

From Amy Goodman’s “Democracy Now” website:

“JUAN GONZALEZ: U.S. diplomatic cables released by WikiLeaks reveal the Bush administration drew up ways to retaliate against Europe for refusing to use genetically modified seeds. In 2007, then-US ambassador to France Craig Stapleton was concerned about France’s decision to ban cultivation of genetically modified corn produced by biotech giant Monsanto. He also warned that a new French environmental review standard could spread anti-biotech policy across Europe.

In the leaked cable, Stapleton writes, quote, “Europe is moving backwards not forwards on this issue with France playing a leading role, along with Austria, Italy and even the [European] Commission…Moving to retaliation will make clear that the current path has real costs to EU interests and could help strengthen European pro-biotech voice.”

AMY GOODMAN: Ambassador Stapleton goes on to write, quote, “Country team Paris recommends that we calibrate a target retaliation list that causes some pain across the EU since this is a collective responsibility, but that also focuses in part on the worst culprits. The list should be measured rather than vicious and must be sustainable over the long term, since we should not expect an early victory,” he wrote.

Well, for more, we’re going to Iowa City to speak with Jeffrey Smith, executive director of the Institute for Responsible Technology, author of two books, Seeds of Deception: Exposing Industry and Government Lies about the Safety of the Genetically Engineered Foods You’re Eating and the book Genetic Roulette: The Documented Health Risks of Genetically Engineered Foods.

Jeffrey Smith, joining us by Democracy Now! video stream, thanks so much for being with us. Talk about the significance of these documents leaked by WikiLeaks.

JEFFREY SMITH: Well, we’ve been saying for years that the United States government has joined at—is joined at the hip with Monsanto and pushing GMOs as part of Monsanto’s agenda on the rest of the world. This lays bare the mechanics of that effort. We have Craig Stapleton, the former ambassador to France, specifically asking the U.S. government to retaliate and cause some harm throughout the European Union. And then, two years later, in 2009, we have a cable from the ambassador to Spain from the United States asking for intervention there, asking the government to help formulate a biotech strategy and support the government—members of the government in Spain that want to promote GMOs, as well. And here, they specifically indicate that they sat with the director of Monsanto for the region and got briefed by him about the politics of the region and created strategies with him to promote the GMO agenda.

JUAN GONZALEZ: Now, they apparently were especially interested in one Monsanto product, MON 810. Could you talk about that?

JEFFREY SMITH: Yes. This is the first seed that was approved for widespread planting. You see, the biotech industry was concerned initially about the European Union accepting genetically modified foods. Although that had been approved for years by the commission, the food industry had rejected it because consumers were concerned. And so, there hasn’t been a lot of food going to the European Union that’s genetically modified.

However, they had planned to allow the growing of genetically modified seeds. Now that MON 810 has been allowed, individual countries have stepped forward to ban in. And so, in 2007, they were concerned about that, and so they were trying to create a strategy to force these countries to accept the first of the genetically modified seeds. Since then, there’s been more evidence showing that this genetically modified corn damages mice and rats, etc., can cause reductions of fertility, smaller litter sizes, smaller offspring, immune responses, etc. And these have gone largely ignored by both the European Food Safety Authority and the United States FDA.

AMY GOODMAN: Talk about these health effects. Jeffrey Smith, you wrote a fascinating “Anniversary of a Whistleblowing Hero” piece about a British scientist and about the repercussions he suffered. He was one of the biggest GMO advocates. And explain what happened and what he actually learned.

JEFFREY SMITH: Well, Dr. Arpad Pusztai was actually working on a $3 million grant from the U.K. government to figure out how to test for the safety of GMOs. And what he discovered quite accidentally is that genetically modified organisms are inherently unsafe. Within 10 days, his supposedly harmless GMO potatoes caused massive damage to rats—smaller brains, livers and testicles, partial atrophy of the liver, damaged immune system, etc. And what he discovered was it was the process, the generic process of genetic engineering, that was likely the cause of the problem. He went public with his concerns and was a hero.

AMY GOODMAN: But I think you have to—Jeffrey Smith, if you could explain this. This is very significant, because he was an expert on the protein that was—it’s this kind of insecticide. And everyone thought, oh, that might be the thing that would hurt people. But he said, actually, it wasn’t the thing that was injected into the—or however it works when you genetically modify a potato, when you put that chemical inside, the protein inside the potato—it wasn’t that.

JEFFREY SMITH: Exactly. You see, he was testing with rats that were eating the genetically modified potato, engineered to produce an insecticidal protein. But he also tested other groups of rats that were eating natural potatoes that were spiked with that same protein, and then a third group that was just eating natural potatoes without the insecticide. Only the group that ate the genetically engineered potato got these problems, not the group that was eating the potatoes along with the insecticide. So it clearly wasn’t the insecticide; it was somehow the process of genetic engineering.

Now, that process creates massive collateral damage inside the DNA of the plant. Hundreds and thousands of mutations can be formed. There could be hundreds or thousands of genes that are natural genes in the plant that change their levels of expression. For example, with MON 810 corn, they found that there was a gene that is normally silent that is switched on and now creates an allergen in corn. They found 43 different genes that were significantly up-regulated or down-regulated, meaning that there’s massive changes in these crops and they’re not being evaluated by the U.S.—by the FDA or any other regulatory authority around the world before being put onto the market.

JUAN GONZALEZ: Now, was there any indication from the cables or from your research that the pressure that Ambassador Stapleton and other U.S. officials were putting on the E.U. had the desired effect? Because obviously Ambassador Stapleton, or former Ambassador Stapleton, was not just any former ambassador, he was the former co-owner of the Texas Rangers with former President George W. Bush.

JEFFREY SMITH: Well, we’ve seen a consistent effort by the U.S. to bully Europe. But, you see, European—the European mind on this is kind of divided. Some countries are clearly in the camp of precautionary principle and protecting interests for health. Others are basically moving in lockstep with the U.S. government and Monsanto. So it’s a fiercely pitched battle on every front in Europe….”

Read more on Democracy Now.

1 Comment

Filed under News

One response to “Wikileaks show how U.S. bullied Europe to permit use of Monsanto’s GMO seeds

  1. It is good to see truthful reporting. Everyone needs to know where “bad” comes from. The things to do are to maintain the “good” and create “good.” We all can understand and learn how all of this “Bad stuff”comes to be but it does take so much of our time. And to tell you the truth, if you are just a simple man or simple person as I am, then you will just drown in all of this information. Use it to know the truth. That is all; and then get in the trenches and fight back. How? Create social networks and organizations that support the truth. Use social media. Create jobs in sustainable agriculture. Start a raw milk dairy farm. Go to the State Capitals and push for good legislation and laws. Be Constitutional. Be a Milkman! Who distributes fresh farm foods, the best of meats, poultry, pork, breads, butter, milk, yogurt, cheese, yummy bacon, fresh farm eggs, fresh juices, and more.

    Right now in the Park Slope section of Brooklyn, New York, exists one of the countries largest CSA organizations. Here also exists one of the largest “underground” raw milk distribution centers in the USA, maybe the world. There are raw milk dealers there like you would not believe. Yes, dealers. New York and other major cities in the USA also have some of the largest numbers of drug dealers too. My point is; where there is strength and a market, the supply for “Goodness” must prevail. You already did hear that there are more “Good” people on the planet than BAD ones. Right? Well, I happen to think that is true. The bad guys are afraid now. They are on the move. And in order to stay in power, they come down harder. They make rules, laws to suit themselves. They are outnumbered. Get up and move. Start a business, anything. Believe it or not, I am one of the few milkman delivery services in the State of Connecticut. I may be the only Milkman service that distributes raw milk. I have one truck. My point is, if I can do this, then someone else can. Someone else with more money, more time,more resources, and smarter than me. Strength also comes in distribution, sales, marketing. That is what a Milkman delivery service does for the supplier, the farmers, sustainable agriculture. Take one milk truck working five days a week with 500 or more customers, multiply that by 2,3,4,5 or more trucks in one vibrant town, buying all fresh farm foods – raw milk and more. And what do you have? You have your Rights. Right to eat good, clean food. The right and ability to support farmers, farm land, open space, sustainable agriculture, vibrant economies, healthy school lunch programs, and more.

    And I am coming out in public to tell you all this. Meanwhile, the Department of Consumer Protection in Connecticut and others are getting ready to shut me down. They were here just the other day. They like to get you when you are weak and alone. When you are afraid to go up against them. The thing they do not know is that right around the corner are individuals and organizations who stand ready to invest their money, time, and soul into ventures like this. It is called, “Investment in Entrepreneurs for Social Good.”

    The establishment, the crooks of societies will drown you in paper. But see how many of them work on a farm or represent themselves as a person with real social humanity.

    Look at what Mark McAfee and his family have done with Organic Pastures. A “GOOD” business that works. Closer to God. Nature. They produce and distribute. Just one example. I can go on and on here.

    The Milkman distribution model works. If you are interested, please do contact me. You have nothing to lose, only yourself. Let them come, and let them beware of the ace in the hole.

    For a cause for the creative spirit………….
    Drawing on groundbreaking brain and behavioral research, a well known author, Daniel Goleman shows the factors at work when people with high IQ flounder and those with modest IQ do surprisingly well. These factors add up to a different way of being smart – one he terms “EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE.” emotional intelligence includes self awareness and impulse control, persistence, zeal and self motivation, empathy and social deftness. These are the qualities he says, and I agree, that mark people who excel in real life: whose intimate relationships flourish, who are stars in the workplace. These are also the hallmarks of character and self discipline, of altruism and compassion – basic capacities needed if our society is to thrive.

    The good news is; Emotional Intelligence is not fixed at birth. As Goleman says, “The true Bell Curve” for democracy must measure emotional intelligence.

    The Milkman is Back!

    Thank you; for this website, your Blog, The Complete Patient, David Gumpert and The Raw Milk Revolution, Michael Schmidt, The Weston A. Price Foundation,,, the raw milk dairies in the world, Ron Schmid, ND and his book “The Untold Story of Milk,” thank God for Indians and Cows, for men like Ghandi, Martin Luther King, Mrs Pabst of the Pabst Blue Ribbon Brewing Company, The Paul Newman Family of Westport, Connecticut, Dr. Harvey’s, my Father – Ed Hartz and Jack Resnick & Sons, My Mother, Mother Earth,Carlo Petrini of The Slow Food Movement, Friends at The Ford Foundation in Manhattan, Governor Rell of Connecticut, Various Underwriters of THE MILKMAN COMPANY in Connecticut, Connecticut Raw Milk Dairies, Connecticut Farmers and Ranchers, The people of Westport and Fairfield Connecticut who support MILKMEN and MILKLADIES. And my Ace in the hole.

    Thank you Weston A.Price.Org for the new publication:

    “AFTER RAW BREAST MILK WHAT’S BEST? – a great brochure. These brochures can be obtained by calling the Weston A. Price Foundation at (202)363.4394 USA.

    God Bless America.
    God Bless you and may you have a blessed holiday season.


    Ed Hartz
    The Milkman
    The Milkman Company
    Milkmen USA

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s