New York state judge rules lab workers CAN be questioned in raw milk case

The latest news on the American raw milk front, from David E. Gumpert of the Complete Patient blog:

We don't really think lab workers wear these when dealing with raw milk samples. See credit at bottom.

“It’s our way of the highway. That’s essentially been the position of New York’s Department of Agriculture & Markets over the last nearly five years, when New York raw dairy farmers have questioned the agency’s testing procedures for listeria in raw milk.

Ag & Markets has, during that time, shuttered half a dozen or so dairies for days on the basis of having supposedly found listeria in raw milk. In a couple cases where dairies have had private tests of split samples they’ve held in reserve that disputed the state’s findings, the response was always the same: Our test is the only one that counts. End of discussion.

Now, Ag & Markets will have to pull back the veil on its testing procedures. That’s because a state judge has ruled that lawyers from the Farm-to-Consumer Legal Defense Fund, representing dairy owner Chuck Phippen, can cross examine state lab workers.

The whole case stems from repeated shutdowns by Ag & Markets of Chuck Phippens’ Breese Hollow dairy in Hoosick Falls for the presence of listeria in its milk. No one has become ill from his milk, or that of any of the other dairies that have been shut down. Phippens refused to pay $800 in fines from two shutdowns, arguing that the state hasn’t provided important details about the lab findings of listeria, and whether the type or amount of listeria actually comprised a health danger. The state brought suit against Phippen.

As part of the suit, the state has fought tooth-and-nail to avoid having its lab workers questioned about not only the details of the findings about listeria at Phippens’ farm, but about the lab’s overall practices….”

Read it all on The Complete Patient blog.

Bio suit photo from this page

Leave a comment

Filed under News

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s