Bechards settle raw milk dispute with Missouri milk board, dating back to ’09

Thanks to Rosanne for first linking to this:

Falls Church, Virginia (August 22, 2012) — Last month Armand and Teddi Bechard entered into a consent agreement with the State of Missouri, ending a case that began in 2009. On two occasions in the spring of 2009, undercover agents from the Springfield-Greene County Health Department allegedly purchased raw milk at the Bechard’s central delivery point, a health food store parking lot in Springfield.

The Missouri State Milk Board through the state attorney filed a lawsuit to enjoin the Bechards from delivering raw milk and cream to their customers at a central distribution point. Missouri statute allows for the sale and delivery of raw milk by unlicensed farmers; however, the Milk Board was insisting that raw milk could only be delivered to the customer’s residence while prohibiting delivery at a central distribution point. The Greene County district attorney’s office also brought a criminal action against Armand for allegedly selling milk at a premises off the farm; he was later acquitted on appeal in January 2011.

FTCLDF General Counsel, Gary Cox, provided the following summary of the settlement:

    On July 31, 2012, Armand and Teddi Bechard entered into a settlement agreement with the Missouri State Milk Board over allegations that the Bechards illegally sold raw milk at a parking lot. The consent judgment, signed by Judge Michael J. Cordonnier, enjoins the Bechards from selling milk to “strangers” who have not previously arranged for the sale and purchase of raw milk from the Bechards.
    However, the Bechards are free to sell raw milk to anyone they want and, after the sale has been arranged, can deliver the raw milk anywhere they want. In fact, the Bechards are allowed to deliver the raw milk to the customer’s home, to a central distribution point like a parking lot in a shopping center, or to the customer at the Bechards’ own farm.
    The prohibition against selling raw milk to “strangers” would mean that the Bechards, when making a delivery to a central distribution point or at any other location, could not sell milk to anyone who “walks up” to them and who has not previously arranged for the sale and purchase of the raw milk. In entering into the consent judgment, the Bechards did not make any admissions to any of the State Milk Board’s claims or allegations.

It’s been a hard three years on the Bechard family.  Watch the video below as Armand briefly tells his story before an audience gathered for a FundRAISER Dinner at the St. Louis Regional Weston A. Price Conference this past May.

More related material on Farm to Consumer.org

2 Comments

Filed under News

2 responses to “Bechards settle raw milk dispute with Missouri milk board, dating back to ’09

  1. Hope you got some cash for your trouble Armond. Now we have the battle of getting rid of the FDA and the health departments. Neither should exist in a free or Christian society

  2. aed939

    Bechard agreed to a settlement restriction which is really not supported by the law. But sounds like they agreed because restriction is really weak. I guess Bechard can just tell a customer: “Walk around the corner and call my cell phone to arrange a sale “in advance.” Then 5 minutes later, come back, and I’ll give you your milk.” All this despite the fact that producer-to-consumer sales are explicitly permitted with no requirement to arrange sales in advance. The only prohibition is on resellers.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s