The BC raw milk court proceedings

Wondering what happened in court out there in B.C. last week, with Fraser Health accusing Michael Schmidt and Gordon Watson of contempt of court? Well, the author of the Bank of Common Sense blog has been public spirited enough to write it all up and post the story, so we can all follow along:

From the Bank of Common Sense:

The accused men, Michael Schmidt and Gordon Watson, with raw milk, on the courthouse steps in British Columbia. Photo from the Food Click image to go to source post.

“Why is raw milk such a contentious issue? I’ve gone through the big picture regarding raw milk in the previous link. But considering in British Columbia this affects a few hundred people, it seems that it’s out of line to spend over $200,000 in court fees.

I just spent a few days watching a court proceeding in the Supreme Court of British Columbia.

The case is for contempt of court – Fraser Health Authority vs. Home on the Range[i]. The matter is so confusing, I’m not even sure if the correct people are in court. As a disclaimer, due to the testimony and cross-examination, sometimes I’m just not sure what the facts are. I’ve attempted to be as accurate as possible, but there might be some mistakes. And this post may be long and boring. As always, summary at the bottom.
Story in chronological order:

  1. A cow share is a private venture with members purchasing a share in a cow and paying someone weekly to take care of the cow. The dividends of the share – milk, yogurt, cheese – were distributed as a dividend.
  2. In June, 2008 – the cow share, which was called “Home on the Range” was inspected and found to be producing raw milk for human consumption.[ii]
  3. There were tests done that showed that the raw milk had excessive bacteria content. Considering that there have been no incidents reported from the members, there is a high probability that the tests were done incorrectly…”[iii]

Read much more on the Bank of Common Sense.


Filed under News

3 responses to “The BC raw milk court proceedings

  1. BC Food Security

    While this article does not clear up the confusion created by the Fraser (so-called) Health Authority itself, this great article clears up some of the confusion about why everything about this issue is so confusing . So now we can rest peacefully in our confusion and the knowing that we are not losing our minds because we are unable to make “head or tails ” about what the heck the Fraser Valley Health Authority thinks it is trying to achieve in this confused situation . Or maybe they don’t actually “think” or have a “goal ” ? Maybe they are just “making it all up as they go along ” ? Confused no more …. ?

  2. Toni

    its about controlling our food supply. The little guy is a threat to the huge government monstrosity because you arent mindlessly letting the etablishment dumb down and chemically enhance your food. How dare you want to produce your own whole food. Thats an offense dont you know.

  3. Pingback: Raw Milk Cure 2013: Day 15

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s