Science-based public policy being eroded in the Canada of 2013

From Carrie Saxifrage, in the Vancouver Observer:

Dr. Katie Gibbs, on Parliament Hill, speaking up for science. Photo via the Vancouver Observer

“Dr. Katie Gibbs has seen her colleagues at the University of Ottawa biology department realize that if anybody in Canada can stand up to the attacks on science, it’s the scientists themselves.

Last spring, as Dr. Gibbs finished up her PhD in conservation biology, the federal government passed Bill C-38, the omnibus legislation that weakened environmental laws such as the Fisheries Act. It also announced that it would cut funding to the Experimental Lakes Area, Canada’s huge contribution to world research on freshwater ecosystems.

These developments awoke the biology department to the need to speak up. They approached Dr. Gibbs, who they knew had attended some protests, and asked if she could help them organize something to bring attention to the devaluation of science by the federal government.

“I watched as the professors realized that they are the ones that have to stand up for science,” Dr. Gibbs said, “that they can’t expect someone else to make the case as to why it is important.”

At the behest of her colleagues, Dr. Gibbs helped organize the Death of Evidence protest in Ottawa, July 2012. Thousands of scientists and their supporters chanted, “No science, no evidence, no truth, no democracy,” as they carried a symbolic coffin to the steps of Parliament Hill.

The success of that protest led to formation of a non profit organization called Evidence for Democracy.  Dr. Gibbs serves as the Executive Director for the group which advocates for the transparent use of evidence in government decision making and public policy development. Although Harper’s science policies catalyzed the new group, its principles are apolitical.

“Government policies affect every aspect of our daily lives,” Dr. Gibbs said. “Using the available evidence assures that we get policies that actually do what they are supposed to do. It’s a better use of tax dollars than just picking what seems to be a good idea at the time.”

Why democracies rely on science

According to Dr. Gibbs, science is absolutely crucial to the major decisions Canada faces regarding resource extraction.

“No one can say what is right and wrong,” Dr. Gibbs said. “That is not a question that science can answer. But good policy requires balancing pros and cons so you have to know what the cons are.”

The problem with the Harper government’s cuts to science research (and the notorious “muzzling of scientists”) is that it can keep citizens from knowing the cons.

“Informed decisions are a fundamental part of democracy,” said Dr. Gibbs. “We need information when we make our minds up about issues and when we elect people.”

Clearing house for evidence

Evidence for Democracy has plans to build a network of experts who will provide information about their research and how it is being used (or not) in forming government policies. An on-line reporting form will simplify information sharing and create data to follow changes in evidence based decision making over time. “We say that [evidence based decision making] has been particularly bad under this government,” Dr. Gibbs said, “but we don’t have a baseline to compare it against. We need that.”….”

Read more in the Vancouver Observer.

The Death of Evidence rally made its way onto Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Tuesday, July 10, 2012. Photograph by: Jean Levac , The Ottawa Citizen. Via

From Teresa Smith, Postmedia News:

“Scientists from across the country staged a mock funeral on Parliament Hill Tuesday to mark what they called “the death of evidence,” protesting government funding cuts to basic research.

Carrying signs accusing the Harper government of a “war on knowledge,” an estimated 2,000 scientists and their supporters walked through the streets of the capital behind a black casket carrying the “body of evidence.”

“We are at a critical point in Canadian history,” said organizer Katie Gibbs, a PhD student at the University of Ottawa. “If we don’t stand up for science, nobody will.”

“No science, no evidence, no truth, no democracy,” they chanted as tourists and onlookers took photos of the walk, which ended on the steps at Parliament Hill.

“Between the sweeping cuts to federal science programs, the legislation changes that we saw in (the omnibus budget) Bill C-38, and the muzzling of scientists, the injuries to evidence have just been overwhelming,” Gibbs told the cheering crowd…..”


Video from the Parliament Hill demonstration


Evidence for Democracy

Science Uncensored

CFIA blocks independent ISA SALMON virus testing lab 

Scientists concerned over chill in reporting Salmon virus after lab delisted

Blog of former Health Canada scientist Shiv Chopra

Click image of text above to go to Science Uncensored’s “take action” page.

Thanks to Raoul Bedi for researching material used in this post.

Leave a comment

Filed under News

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s